This place was awesome! So many people told us to go here when we were in Maui and it did not disappoint! The view was incredible and the food was delicious! Their cocktails are amazing too! Brad took great care of us and was kind enough to take a photo of us when we asked him. They even gave us a thoughtful note at the table since they knew we were on our honeymoon! Would definitely recommend. Make sure to get a reservation early as in before you even leave for your trip! They fill up quick. Also go during the day or at least before it gets dark so you can enjoy the view!
Julia Moore
-
November 28, 2025
First off, Alexa was the best server I have ever had anywhere! Everything else about our experience was perfection. The restaurant is absolutely gorgeous. And everyone in my party of 9 could agree that we were eating the best seafood we had ever had and will probably ever have in our lives. We probably ordered everything on the menu and every single dish was stunning. The crab cakes, crudo dishes, short ribs, lobster, kanpachi all left me speechless. I’m so grateful I got to experience mama’s fish house, and if you’re gonna splurge anywhere in the COUNTRY this is the place
Ben Bar-Lev
-
November 03, 2025
Just finished a 5 day trip to Maui w my wife and this was an absolute highlight.
One of the tougher reservations to get, booked ours far in advance, expectations were high — i was worried.
After eating here & experiencing the service,
I now understand what the hype is about.
You can see this isn’t just a restaurant , it’s an institution & has this refined confidence about them — been here for years, they have perfected the service & food offering.
Complimentary valet, a beautiful private beach, and a great ratio of staff to guests.
My wife, 25 weeks pregnant & eats plant based, had many options curated for her & i can genuinely say, being from California where vegan food is plentiful, she’s never had more options at a traditionally seafood heavy restaurant than she did at mamas. 3 different entree’s, custom & thoughtful adjustments — our server maile made us feel comfortable from the minute we sat down.
The Maui onion tomato salad w/ the 18 year balsamic is something I’ll be making in the future as it was just simple & executed perfectly — again, refined confidence.
I also got the octopus dish that was well seasoned and had bright flavors to it - would recommend.
There was a hiccup in my wife’s entree & it was handled superbly — immediately took the dish back, expedited a new dish, and when it came out, they gave me a sauce to rewarm my meal as they saw i waited for my wife’s food to come out. Just awareness you don’t see that often.
I got the stuffed amberjack w crab & lobster w macadamia hit crust and it just blew me away — simply the best.
We had such a good time we bought a t shirt !
Josiah Utsch
-
November 27, 2025
The fish and fruits were incredibly fresh and vibrant. I was surprised at how much of a fine dining experience it was. The gorgeous platings and crisp flavors would easily be at home in a Michelin starred restaurant tasting menu. The highlight of the meal was the incredible crudo section featuring local fishes. Of special note are the creamy, bright ahi poisson cru and spicy, acidic onaga ceviche. Even small touches such as turmeric pickled ginger and fresh local banana with Mac nut were capable of stunning. Tangy Lilikoi crème brule perfectly rounded out the meal.
Arturs Mons
-
October 13, 2025
Mamma’s Fish House truly delivers on the experience — the food is fresh and beautifully prepared, the drinks are excellent, and the service is warm and attentive. Everything feels polished and full of aloha spirit.
That said, the price point doesn’t quite match up — it’s definitely on the higher end, and some of the dishes feel a bit overpriced, which makes it seem more about the hype than pure value. Still, the overall experience, atmosphere, and views make it worth visiting at least once. It’s a Maui classic and a must-do spot on the island for anyone who wants to enjoy a memorable meal in a stunning setting.
This place was awesome! So many people told us to go here when we were in Maui and it did not disappoint! The view was incredible and the food was delicious! Their cocktails are amazing too! Brad took great care of us and was kind enough to take a photo of us when we asked him. They even gave us a thoughtful note at the table since they knew we were on our honeymoon! Would definitely recommend. Make sure to get a reservation early as in before you even leave for your trip! They fill up quick. Also go during the day or at least before it gets dark so you can enjoy the view!
First off, Alexa was the best server I have ever had anywhere! Everything else about our experience was perfection. The restaurant is absolutely gorgeous. And everyone in my party of 9 could agree that we were eating the best seafood we had ever had and will probably ever have in our lives. We probably ordered everything on the menu and every single dish was stunning. The crab cakes, crudo dishes, short ribs, lobster, kanpachi all left me speechless. I’m so grateful I got to experience mama’s fish house, and if you’re gonna splurge anywhere in the COUNTRY this is the place
Just finished a 5 day trip to Maui w my wife and this was an absolute highlight. One of the tougher reservations to get, booked ours far in advance, expectations were high — i was worried. After eating here & experiencing the service, I now understand what the hype is about. You can see this isn’t just a restaurant , it’s an institution & has this refined confidence about them — been here for years, they have perfected the service & food offering. Complimentary valet, a beautiful private beach, and a great ratio of staff to guests. My wife, 25 weeks pregnant & eats plant based, had many options curated for her & i can genuinely say, being from California where vegan food is plentiful, she’s never had more options at a traditionally seafood heavy restaurant than she did at mamas. 3 different entree’s, custom & thoughtful adjustments — our server maile made us feel comfortable from the minute we sat down. The Maui onion tomato salad w/ the 18 year balsamic is something I’ll be making in the future as it was just simple & executed perfectly — again, refined confidence. I also got the octopus dish that was well seasoned and had bright flavors to it - would recommend. There was a hiccup in my wife’s entree & it was handled superbly — immediately took the dish back, expedited a new dish, and when it came out, they gave me a sauce to rewarm my meal as they saw i waited for my wife’s food to come out. Just awareness you don’t see that often. I got the stuffed amberjack w crab & lobster w macadamia hit crust and it just blew me away — simply the best. We had such a good time we bought a t shirt !
The fish and fruits were incredibly fresh and vibrant. I was surprised at how much of a fine dining experience it was. The gorgeous platings and crisp flavors would easily be at home in a Michelin starred restaurant tasting menu. The highlight of the meal was the incredible crudo section featuring local fishes. Of special note are the creamy, bright ahi poisson cru and spicy, acidic onaga ceviche. Even small touches such as turmeric pickled ginger and fresh local banana with Mac nut were capable of stunning. Tangy Lilikoi crème brule perfectly rounded out the meal.
Mamma’s Fish House truly delivers on the experience — the food is fresh and beautifully prepared, the drinks are excellent, and the service is warm and attentive. Everything feels polished and full of aloha spirit. That said, the price point doesn’t quite match up — it’s definitely on the higher end, and some of the dishes feel a bit overpriced, which makes it seem more about the hype than pure value. Still, the overall experience, atmosphere, and views make it worth visiting at least once. It’s a Maui classic and a must-do spot on the island for anyone who wants to enjoy a memorable meal in a stunning setting.