Maui's second Dominos has opened up shop in the Puunene Shopping Center.
ATMOSPHERE:
Compared to the Maui Lani SC location, this one has a lot more (indoor) seating and is pretty spacious. Parking is plentiful and close as the shared building isn't fully occupied yet.
FOOD:
Handmade Pan ExtravaganZZa
The handmade pan crust is my favorite as its soft and chewy though available only in small and medium sizes for some odd reason. The ExtravaganZZA category of toppings is their version of supreme and includes pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, beef, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives. Red or white sauce is available. What I like about Dominos over Pizza Hut is that their toppings go all the way to the edge of the pizza. Taste-wise, I'd rather have the Hut, but I had a gift card to use here.
SERVICE:
I ordered online and the pizza was ready for pick up within the time span of 20 minutes (I always carryout). They seemed understaffed. A friendly guy greeted me at the counter but had to call over another staff member to cash me out. The gal who came had pizza ingredients all over her hands, making me wonder why she wasn't using gloves. I really hope she washed them again after handling my payment. Eek.
OVERALL:
Dominos isn't the good deal they once were when they first re-opened on Maui. Coupons are limited to a miniscule amount of toppings just like their competitors. For this location, what would've been a 4-star review is now a 3 due to that sanitation issue.
Nina Williams
-
January 04, 2026
I placed an order on 01/03/26 for the 3 topping pizza. I ordered online. My toppings were Extra Itailian Sausage, Beef and Pepperoni, when I got to the store to pickup I notice, extra Pepperoni and less meat, which the guy read it wrong, he stated he could add more meat and run it back in tbe oven, I said who does that, he said because they were short on dough, and quality assurance and control they couldn't remake me another pizza, I went back and forth with them until they decided to remake the pizza. Worst experience ever.
Kyle Frederick Delos Santos
-
September 06, 2025
I usually don’t write reviews but I was disappointed with the service. I order on the app and was told my order was ready. Walked into the store and was told they mixed up my pizza. Took them around 8 mins to make a new one. However they forgot one of the toppings so I had to wait another 8 mins. On top of that my wings barely had any sauce on them to the point I would consider them plain. However I got to annoyed and accepted the fact, that’s what I’m getting.
Jeff Eng
-
December 09, 2025
Recently I experienced a drop off in the quality of the pizzas. However, thanks to manager Jay, he resolved the issue and I’m very pleased to say that the pizza quality is as good as before.
Joselito Sams
-
November 24, 2024
Aloha Love Pizza, Definitely ADD 10-20mins for a pick up order. The pizza is hit or miss. 50/50 Depending on who is working….Target Pizza is never burnt and is more consistent… Seafood City much better after watching 45mins for pickup.
Maui's second Dominos has opened up shop in the Puunene Shopping Center. ATMOSPHERE: Compared to the Maui Lani SC location, this one has a lot more (indoor) seating and is pretty spacious. Parking is plentiful and close as the shared building isn't fully occupied yet. FOOD: Handmade Pan ExtravaganZZa The handmade pan crust is my favorite as its soft and chewy though available only in small and medium sizes for some odd reason. The ExtravaganZZA category of toppings is their version of supreme and includes pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, beef, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives. Red or white sauce is available. What I like about Dominos over Pizza Hut is that their toppings go all the way to the edge of the pizza. Taste-wise, I'd rather have the Hut, but I had a gift card to use here. SERVICE: I ordered online and the pizza was ready for pick up within the time span of 20 minutes (I always carryout). They seemed understaffed. A friendly guy greeted me at the counter but had to call over another staff member to cash me out. The gal who came had pizza ingredients all over her hands, making me wonder why she wasn't using gloves. I really hope she washed them again after handling my payment. Eek. OVERALL: Dominos isn't the good deal they once were when they first re-opened on Maui. Coupons are limited to a miniscule amount of toppings just like their competitors. For this location, what would've been a 4-star review is now a 3 due to that sanitation issue.
I placed an order on 01/03/26 for the 3 topping pizza. I ordered online. My toppings were Extra Itailian Sausage, Beef and Pepperoni, when I got to the store to pickup I notice, extra Pepperoni and less meat, which the guy read it wrong, he stated he could add more meat and run it back in tbe oven, I said who does that, he said because they were short on dough, and quality assurance and control they couldn't remake me another pizza, I went back and forth with them until they decided to remake the pizza. Worst experience ever.
I usually don’t write reviews but I was disappointed with the service. I order on the app and was told my order was ready. Walked into the store and was told they mixed up my pizza. Took them around 8 mins to make a new one. However they forgot one of the toppings so I had to wait another 8 mins. On top of that my wings barely had any sauce on them to the point I would consider them plain. However I got to annoyed and accepted the fact, that’s what I’m getting.
Recently I experienced a drop off in the quality of the pizzas. However, thanks to manager Jay, he resolved the issue and I’m very pleased to say that the pizza quality is as good as before.
Aloha Love Pizza, Definitely ADD 10-20mins for a pick up order. The pizza is hit or miss. 50/50 Depending on who is working….Target Pizza is never burnt and is more consistent… Seafood City much better after watching 45mins for pickup.