Had an excellent meal at Paia FishMarket during our visit to Maui. The highlight was definitely the blackened Mahi Mahi! perfectly seasoned, incredibly fresh, and cooked just right with a flavorful crust that brought out the natural taste of the fish. The portions were generous, the service was quick, and the casual island atmosphere made for a great dining experience. If you’re looking for fresh seafood in Maui, this place is absolutely worth a visit. I’ll definitely be back for that blackened Mahi Mahi!
Nathan Miner
-
June 24, 2026
Visited on our last evening in Maui on Monday Jun 22, 2026. I am not exaggerating when I say it was the best meal I have had in at least 15 years. I wanted to personally thanks the chefs and management but it was too busy so I just told the waitress to pass on the message. We had the Seafood pasta, Charbroiled Mahi Mahi with Cajun rice, shrimp tacos, fish tacos, and a side of Onion Rings. Everything was amazing but the best things was the Seafood pasta, Mahi Mahi, and Onion Rings. Would highly recommend.
Travel Wizard
-
June 08, 2026
You walk up to the counter and order which fish and how you want it with a sides, get a drink and pick a table to sit at. They bring out some of the best food I had all week in Maui. It was delicious and so flavorful. You’re not going to be wined and dined but the food is very tasty. I highly recommend you take the time to eat here.
The small town of Paia is very cute also. Spend some time in the shops and get lost here.
E L
-
May 29, 2026
This was recommended by so many people & there’s always a queue - goes down fast though. It was nice but I thought it was abit overhyped. The fish was quite dry but collectively as a dish with the rice & coleslaw, it was satisfying. Tacos were decent
Cheri
-
May 04, 2026
I tried their fish tacos and calamari. My mom got their pasta. All the food was great! I know this sounds silly but I also enjoyed the fountain Diet Coke drink. A nice cold fountain drink is hard to come by in Hawaii. You order you food at the counter and the bring you your food. There was a little line but it went quick and they got the food out quick too. I would definitely go back.
Had an excellent meal at Paia FishMarket during our visit to Maui. The highlight was definitely the blackened Mahi Mahi! perfectly seasoned, incredibly fresh, and cooked just right with a flavorful crust that brought out the natural taste of the fish. The portions were generous, the service was quick, and the casual island atmosphere made for a great dining experience. If you’re looking for fresh seafood in Maui, this place is absolutely worth a visit. I’ll definitely be back for that blackened Mahi Mahi!
Visited on our last evening in Maui on Monday Jun 22, 2026. I am not exaggerating when I say it was the best meal I have had in at least 15 years. I wanted to personally thanks the chefs and management but it was too busy so I just told the waitress to pass on the message. We had the Seafood pasta, Charbroiled Mahi Mahi with Cajun rice, shrimp tacos, fish tacos, and a side of Onion Rings. Everything was amazing but the best things was the Seafood pasta, Mahi Mahi, and Onion Rings. Would highly recommend.
You walk up to the counter and order which fish and how you want it with a sides, get a drink and pick a table to sit at. They bring out some of the best food I had all week in Maui. It was delicious and so flavorful. You’re not going to be wined and dined but the food is very tasty. I highly recommend you take the time to eat here. The small town of Paia is very cute also. Spend some time in the shops and get lost here.
This was recommended by so many people & there’s always a queue - goes down fast though. It was nice but I thought it was abit overhyped. The fish was quite dry but collectively as a dish with the rice & coleslaw, it was satisfying. Tacos were decent
I tried their fish tacos and calamari. My mom got their pasta. All the food was great! I know this sounds silly but I also enjoyed the fountain Diet Coke drink. A nice cold fountain drink is hard to come by in Hawaii. You order you food at the counter and the bring you your food. There was a little line but it went quick and they got the food out quick too. I would definitely go back.