Pizza Madness Maui

1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

About Pizza Madness Maui

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Casual, art-lined eatery serving choose-your-own-topping pizzas, salads & sandwiches.

    Will Ellis
    -
    July 30, 2025

    Incredibly delicious! The best pizza Iโ€™ve had in a really long time. Keno was a fantastic server and shared everything is made fresh daily - never frozen. Itโ€™s tried & true which shows in the quality of pizza. We definitely recommend

    Vince Ponciano
    -
    July 12, 2025

    Seated right away. The place filled up quickly after we were seated . There were a lot of take out orders between the time we ordered and we had to ask our waitress where we were in line for a pie. She asked the cook and got our pizza out to us within 5 minutes. The 3 servers were busy with other tables, and we had to ask for drink refills as they passed by. Great pizza but maybe they are short staffed during dinner hours?

    Katherine Amanda
    -
    June 19, 2025

    This pizza tasted very good, but I ordered a Hawaiian pizza and it came with not one single piece of pineapple. So thereโ€™s that. When I tried calling, it said their mailbox was full and they were unreachable - hence this review. So disappointingโ€ฆ when I went to their menu I saw that this pizza is the meat one. I got the wrong pizza altogether. On the bright side, at least it was good!

    Raina Studer
    -
    August 08, 2025

    This is a bar/restaurant and quite dark inside so leans more bar vibe. Our children enjoyed the art work of the octopus, fish, shark and turtle eating pizza slices. Also the walls make you feel a bit like youโ€™re inside a ship. Our children also enjoyed the pizza, although us parents thought it was a bit like Costco crust taste/texture. My husband had the โ€œsuperโ€ sandwich . He felt it needed a bit more sauce. I had the kalua pork sandwich. It had bbq sauce, melted white cheese. Iโ€™d omit the bbq sauce. It overpowered the flavors. The kalua pork and slaw alone would make a great sandwich. The sandwich bread was great! Soft, a little chewy and crispy. Perfect. The Caesar salad dressing was really delicious. Great creamy texture and flavor! The desserts: we ordered Maui made ice cream cookie sandwich Chocolate ice cream with Mac nut cookie (always delicious) and ube cheesecake. The ube cheesecake is skippable. The ube cake has a little bit of a food coloring flavoring that throws it off. Our server was attentive however when it became busy we could see she was doing her best and managing too much for one person (checks, drinks, meal delivery, busing tables, bar, wow! I think she even was responsible for playing salads and desserts! She was doing well despite how much she was responsible for in the restaurant.

    Alayna Davies-Smith
    -
    September 16, 2025

    Pretty decent pizza...not the best I've ever had but better than average .. pepperoni came out cheesy & hot. Anti pasta salad (half) was full of meat, salami, turkey, ham. Garlic fries average. Service was top notch! Got seated and served right away. Small, family friendly sports bar atmosphere.

    Pizza Madness Maui

    Our Address

    1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!