Pizza Madness Maui

1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

About Pizza Madness Maui

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Casual, art-lined eatery serving choose-your-own-topping pizzas, salads & sandwiches.

    Terrence Reed
    -
    January 26, 2025

    Wonderful atmosphere with great service! One of the most responsible priced restaurants weโ€™ve been to in this island. The wings were very good and extra crispy! We got the Salt and Vinegar and loved them! The pizza is good! The menu says itโ€™s thin crust, but itโ€™s not. Decent amount of pork on our Kalua Pork Pizza. Wouldโ€™ve liked about double just to get an adequate amount in each slice. Pineapple is from a can. Not bad but would LOVE to have some local Maui Gold triangles on the pizza.

    AJ
    -
    February 26, 2025

    Came in for a happy hour deal of a beer & personal pizza for $15. Decent deal. Pizza was quite good. Got the Hawaiian and the pep + onion. The interior is dark and desolate - definitely in need of an update though. Also would suggest they use actual Maui pineapple rather than pineapple from a can. Told the server that and the response was that they go bad fast and are more expensive. Ok, fair. But fresh is always better.

    William Boyer
    -
    February 14, 2025

    Went for what I thought was a quick lunch before a meeting. No luck. The place was empty except for a couple at the bar, already eating, and one table of 3. Oh, and several employees sitting at a table too. I ordered a mini (4 slices) and it took 30 minutes. Pizza dough was thick and mushy, not completely cooked. I asked for mushrooms and sausage, and got sausage and cheese. Could not alert them as I had to take it to go since it took so long. This place has a great reputation, but I was not impressed. $25 for mini pizza and a small (really small) glass of tap beer. Ugh.

    Shruti P
    -
    March 11, 2025

    Thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and garlic bread! Might go back just for the garlic bread! The system malfunctioned while taking it order, so the kitchen prepared the wrong pizza, but the staff was kind enough to remake it for us!

    Lissa Newton
    -
    November 17, 2024

    Pizza is like a food group for me, so when I state this pizza was terrific I mean it from my cholesterol-laden, cheese-loving, crust-enjoying little heart. The wings were good too, and hey, salad.

    Pizza Madness Maui

    Our Address

    1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!