Pizza Madness Maui

1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

About Pizza Madness Maui

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Casual, art-lined eatery serving choose-your-own-topping pizzas, salads & sandwiches.

    Mark Yambor
    May 07, 2024

    We had a long day out exploring the island and felt like having a good pizza to close out the day. This place was a short drive from our resort so we decided to give a try. We were seated right away as it wasn't that busy when we went and ordered right away. We both liked our pizzas and what made it better was the incredibly friendly service that we received while there. The crust was done quite well and we enjoyed the toppings. It was a good experience and worth our money.

    Al Bartos
    March 25, 2024

    Went here in 2010. Bought the T-Shirt because it was the best pizza I’d ever consumed. Now 14 years later, we went back. Bought another T-Shirt and I still believe this is the best I’ve ever had and certainly the best on the island. Sad to hear about the owners passing but very happy that his legacy lives on with the current owners/employees 😎 If you’re in Kehei don’t miss an opportunity to enjoy some fine food, drink and hospitality.

    Travis Hizall
    September 12, 2023

    The pizza was outstanding. Wings need improvement. Typical atmosphere. Great service. Drink selections were pretty decent. The wife had wine, and I had a local craft beer. I had wings and shared a 10-inch pizza with my wife. We had 3 slices left over. She says among the best pizzas she's ever had. The wings were good, but I don't like the way they did them. They were basically fried chicken with your ordered sauce on the side. I ordered the hot wings. The sauce was simply Frank's hot sauce or some varient of it. When I order wings, I expect the sauce to be different from other hot wings, as in this chef putting his signature into it. Using the same simple sauce as everyone else degrades the experience. Also, I'd prefer tossed wings than just having sauce on the side. I poured the sauce on my wings, and it was not near enough, only partly covering one side of the wings. I asked for more sauce and was quickly accommodated. Besides the sauce, the fried chicken wings were really good, cooked perfect with the perfect amount of crisp on the outside. The atmosphere was pretty typical for a place like this. Good, but I also didn't see anything that made them stand out. One worth mention is that all their TVs are on one side of the dining area. If you're facing the doors, you can't see a single TV, see pictures. Overall, I do recommend stopping in and getting full.

    Jordan Hodges
    July 15, 2023

    Was okay. Was recommended to try this spot by a local. Service was poor. Bro with a pony tail literally played games on his phone while being short with a customer. Place was cool but they left the dining area dirty. Pizza was “so so”. Poppers were your standard frozen then fried verity. Ranch dressing was house made and good. Lol My boys did like the spaghetti. We bought two of the “sides of spaghetti”. Added the 1.00 meatballs. They were very small. For the price this place would be a “pass” for me. Top level price for garden verity pizza IMO.

    Sagar Vora
    May 22, 2024

    We ordered a veggie pizza and it tasted amazing. We also ordered a garlic bread and that was good too. The service was quick and the vibe was good. It’s mainly for pizza with a drink but we enjoyed our time there. One thing we liked the most was that the pizza had lot of veggies, not a lot of veggie pizzas have them so we liked that it had lots of veggies. A 10 slice was enough for 2 ppl but we thought it was a bit expensive for the size.

    Pizza Madness Maui

    Our Address

    1455 S Kihei Rd # 2, Kihei, HI 96753, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!